Homemade Cherry Pie Filling Recipe - Chocolate Covered Katie (2024)

Here’s an easy recipe for how to make homemade cherry pie filling to use in pies, cakes, cheesecakes, or simply to eat with a spoon!

Just one spoon of this thick and delicious cherry pie filling, and you will never go back to canned cherry pie filling again.

The easy recipe can be naturally sweetened, with no high fructose corn syrup, no Red 40, and no gelatin required. And it tastes ten times better than the canned version!

Also try these popular Oreo Cupcakes

Ways to use cherry pie filling

This cherry filling is perfect in Chia Pudding or Overnight Oats.

Stir it into parfaits or yogurt, use as a topping for black forest cake or cheesecake, or spoon it over pancakes, crepes, French toast, or waffles.

Or use the thick cherry sauce to make turnovers or pop tarts, hand pies or bars, cherry fluff salad, or cherry cobblers or crumbles.

Of course, the most popular way to use cherry pie filling is in a homemade cherry pie.

It’s a great topping for Keto Cheesecake or No Bake Cheesecake

Above, watch the step-by-step cherry pie filling recipe video

Homemade cherry pie filling ingredients

The cherry topping recipe calls for cherries, water, lemon juice, sweetener of choice, cornstarch, optional pinch of salt, and pure vanilla extract or almond extract.

The sweetener can be granulated, like regular sugar or coconut sugar. Or you can use an unrefined liquid sweetener like honey, agave, or pure maple syrup. For sugar free cherry desserts, use erythritol or xylitol.

I have not tried arrowroot, tapioca, agar, flour, or other substitutes for the cornstarch. Feel free to experiment, and be sure to report back if you do.

What type of cherries?

Sweet cherries or sour cherries both work in the recipe. I like sweet black cherries, such as Bing, Lambert, Chelan, or Sweetheart. If using tart or red cherries, add more sweetener to taste if needed.

I prefer to use frozen cherries simply because they are usually already pitted, so it saves you the step of having to pit cherries by hand.

Fresh cherries are fine to use as long as you pit them first with a chopstick or knife, or with a cherry pitter.

Extra cherries? Make Cherry Frozen Yogurt

How to make cherry pie filling

Combine all ingredients except the vanilla extract in a saucepan.

Bring the mixture to a boil over medium heat, then turn the heat to low once it starts to boil. Stir frequently until the cherries are super soft and the juice is thick. This should take around ten to fifteen minutes on the stove top.

Turn off the heat. Whisk in the vanilla extract. You can also add a drop or two of almond extract if you wish. Taste, and add additional sweetener if needed.

Let the cherry mixture cool before transferring to mason jars or an airtight lidded container. Store leftovers covered in the refrigerator for up to a week. Or freeze for up to three months, thawing before using.

Fresh or canned cherries

There are many brands of cherry pie filling from a can on the market, including Comstock (Duncan Hines), Solo, Lucky Leaf, Musselman’s, Giant, Walmart, and Target.

Most canned options either contain artificial color or corn syrup or are expensive. So the best choice for healthy cherry pie filling is to make your own at home.

As mentioned earlier, homemade cherry filling also just tastes better.

Easy Cake & Pie Recipes

Crustless Pumpkin Pie

Deep Dish Cookie Pie

Pineapple Pie

Keto Cake

Vegan Apple Pie

Vanilla Mug Cake

Applesauce Cake